Talk:Smithing/@comment-104.11.211.102-20150612064921/@comment-26478543-20150616215328

I should have mentioned that there were a handful of duds when trying the recipe with the various emas. I probably had about as many duds as I did actual successes in getting rare swords. Maybe I'm an exception, but considering I got all of the rare swords with a few days and during my first week of playing, a ratio of 4 or 5 duds to 8 rare swords isn't bad at all.