Talk:Hirano Toushirou/@comment-26478543-20150614175155

After accidentally using Hirano to refine another sword, realized it a few days after I got her from a drop, I set out to get her again by grinding the 3-2 map and forging for her. After 20+ times using the 50/50/50/50 recipe and using the other recommended recipes several times, I got her again, and Atsu, with the 71/71/71/71 recipe that others have recommended in the comments.

I got Atsu on my first attempt with this recipe and then got Hirano about my 4th or 5th try. It seems to be a great recipe for the rare Tantous. At least, from my experience.